Anime protagonists often face immense challenges, and Monkey D. Luffy from One Piece is no exception. Having witnessed the apparent death of his foster brother, Sabo, and the devastating loss of his crewmate, Ace, Luffy has experienced trauma that nearly shattered him. Despite these hardships, Luffy found solace and strength through the support of his friends, particularly Jimbei and his crew, and overcame these personal battles during the two-year time skip.
However, Luffy’s struggles are not unique in the world of anime. Several characters have endured even greater hardships, ranging from extreme grief to betrayal, injuries, and relentless suffering. While Luffy’s losses were profound, other characters have faced even darker journeys, often changing them irreparably. Here are 10 anime characters who experienced more intense suffering than Luffy.
1. Guts from Berserk – A Life of Endless Suffering
Guts, the protagonist of Berserk, is often called the “Struggler” due to the nightmarish hardships he’s endured since childhood. Guts’ story is one of relentless violence, betrayal, and tragedy. From his infancy, when he was left to die and raised in a brutal mercenary band, Guts faced unimaginable suffering. At age nine, he was subjected to horrific abuse and betrayal by his father figure, Gambino. Over the years, Guts became a formidable warrior, but his suffering only escalated, especially when Griffith, his closest companion, betrayed him during the Eclipse. Guts lost his left hand, his right eye, and his humanity, yet he continued to fight, never surrendering to the darkness that sought to consume him.
2. Thorfinn Karlsefni from Vinland Saga – A Life Defined by Revenge and Loss
Thorfinn’s early years in Vinland Saga were filled with happiness, until his father, Thors, was tragically killed in front of him. Thorfinn’s life was subsequently consumed by a thirst for revenge, leading him down a dark path of violence and hatred. His quest for vengeance was ultimately meaningless when Prince Canute killed Askeladd, the man responsible for his father’s death, leaving Thorfinn without purpose. This loss led to Thorfinn becoming a slave, where he confronted his past actions and sought a new path of peace and self-redemption. Despite his traumatic experiences, Thorfinn’s growth reflects the possibility of healing even after deep trauma.
3. Edward Elric from Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – A Price Paid for Ambition
Edward Elric’s journey in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is marked by immense personal loss and tragic decisions. As a child, Edward and his brother, Alphonse, tried to bring their mother back to life through forbidden alchemy, resulting in a horrific accident that left Alphonse without a body and Edward without an arm and a leg. The brothers’ quest for the Philosopher’s Stone led them into a world of bloodshed, betrayal, and profound loss. Edward’s determination to rectify his mistakes was constantly tested, and his efforts often resulted in even greater suffering. His journey is one of growth, sacrifice, and the pursuit of redemption.
4. Denji from Chainsaw Man – A Life of Loss and Betrayal
Denji, the protagonist of Chainsaw Man, grew up in poverty, scraping by as a debt-ridden orphan. His life took a turn when he merged with his pet devil, Pochita, becoming the titular Chainsaw Man after his death at the hands of the Zombie Devil. Though Denji hoped that working under the enigmatic Makima would bring him stability, his life only became more tragic. He lost his friends one by one, watching Makima kill Power and being forced to kill his close friend Aki. Denji’s journey through betrayal, loss, and the trauma of never knowing peace shows a stark contrast to Luffy’s more hopeful journey.
5. Kyo Sohma from Fruits Basket – A Lifetime of Hatred and Imprisonment
Kyo Sohma’s life in Fruits Basket was one of rejection and hatred, as he was ostracized by his entire family due to the curse that bound him to the spirit of the housecat. Kyo’s struggles were compounded by his father’s rejection and the belief that he had caused his mother’s death. He faced imprisonment within the Sohma compound, an existence defined by isolation and self-loathing. However, through his relationship with Tohru Honda, Kyo gradually overcame his trauma, finding freedom and acceptance in a world that had long condemned him.
6. Ken Kaneki from Tokyo Ghoul – Tortured by His Own Existence
Ken Kaneki, the protagonist of Tokyo Ghoul, underwent a life-altering transformation when he was turned into a half-ghoul after a near-fatal accident. Struggling with his identity and the violent nature of his powers, Kaneki was subjected to intense torture at the hands of Yamori in the Aogiri Tree. This experience, along with the constant battle between ghouls and humans, led Kaneki down a dark path. His tortured soul became a central theme of his journey, and his quest for peace often came at great personal cost, including the loss of friends and the constant emotional and physical trauma he endured.
7. Eren Yeager from Attack on Titan – A Cycle of Violence and Destruction
Eren Yeager’s life in Attack on Titan was defined by endless trauma and loss. After witnessing the brutal death of his mother at the hands of Titans, Eren swore vengeance against them. Throughout the series, he suffered more losses, including the deaths of friends and countless battles that left him scarred. Eren’s descent into villainy, driven by his resolve to destroy the world with the Rumbling, illustrates the psychological toll of his traumatic experiences. His transformation from a child seeking justice to a man willing to annihilate humanity is a tragic reflection of the corrosive power of trauma.
8. Nina Tucker from Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – The Ultimate Tragedy
Nina Tucker’s fate in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood stands as one of the most heartbreaking in anime. A victim of her father’s twisted experiments, Nina was transformed into a chimera, an abomination that combined her body with that of a dog. Her tragic end came when she was killed by the monstrous creature her father had created. Nina’s brief and innocent life serves as a chilling reminder of the depths of human cruelty and the devastating effects of trauma on even the youngest and most innocent characters.
9. Shinji Ikari from Neon Genesis Evangelion – A Battle Against Himself
Shinji Ikari from Neon Genesis Evangelion faced extreme emotional trauma throughout the series. Raised in a neglectful environment by his distant father, Shinji’s self-worth was crushed under the weight of constant rejection. He struggled to find meaning in his life while piloting the powerful Eva unit against the monstrous Angels. The series’ exploration of Shinji’s mental and emotional battles underscores the devastating effects of isolation and the pressure of being thrust into a world of violence and existential crisis.
10. Saitama from One Punch Man – The Burden of Undefeated Power
While Saitama from One Punch Man is often seen as a comical figure, his own form of trauma lies in the emptiness he feels from being too powerful. Saitama’s ability to defeat any opponent with a single punch has led to a deep sense of loneliness, as he no longer finds joy or excitement in combat. His existential crisis, while less conventional than physical or emotional trauma, is a unique form of suffering in a world that no longer provides him with meaningful challenges.
These characters, like Luffy, embody the resilience required to survive in their respective worlds. While Luffy’s journey is undeniably filled with emotional pain and loss, these anime characters have experienced even more profound traumas that shaped their identities in complex and sometimes tragic ways.
Related Topics
Top 10 Best Demon Slayer Characters
How Many Warlords Are There In One Piece?
Female Characters in Shangri-La Frontier Defy Expectations