While shonen anime has become a dominant force worldwide, with franchises like Dragon Ball, Naruto, and One Piece dominating global markets, not every series within the genre achieves the same level of international success. Kinnikuman, a foundational series in the development of the battle shonen genre, has remained a cultural staple in Japan but has largely failed to capture the attention of audiences abroad.
Kinnikuman’s Legacy in Japan
Created in 1979 by Yoshinori Nakai and Takashi Shimada, Kinnikuman follows the adventures of Suguru Kinniku, a goofy superhero who must win a series of wrestling tournaments to retain his status as prince of his alien race. The series is both a parody of tokusatsu superheroes like Ultraman and a tribute to Japanese professional wrestling. While it has maintained enduring popularity in Japan, Kinnikuman has struggled to break into Western markets.
Cultural Barriers to Success
The humor and themes of Kinnikuman, which are deeply rooted in Japanese wrestling culture and the Ultraman franchise, are often unfamiliar to international viewers. Early attempts to introduce the series to the West, such as the M.U.S.C.L.E. toy line in the 1980s and the 2000s English dub of Ultimate Muscle (a sequel to Kinnikuman), failed to resonate with audiences. The series’ niche appeal, combined with the challenge of introducing a culture-specific story to a foreign audience, contributed to its lack of success.
Influence on Modern Shonen Tropes
Despite its failure to make an impact outside Japan, Kinnikuman was a pioneer in many elements that have since become hallmarks of the shonen genre. The concept of power-ups and tournament arcs, for instance, became central to later hits like Dragon Ball Z. Additionally, the trend of villains becoming allies—a trope popularized by characters such as Vegeta in Dragon Ball—originated in Kinnikuman. Yet, these innovations have often been overshadowed by the more widespread success of later series that drew from the same well of inspiration.
A Wider Trend of Disappearing Classics
Kinnikuman is not alone in its struggle for international recognition. Saint Seiya (Knights of the Zodiac), another influential series that helped shape shonen conventions, also failed to gain significant traction in the U.S. Despite being a major hit in Latin America and Europe, Saint Seiya’s early Western releases failed to captivate a new generation of anime fans, overshadowed by the arrival of series like Dragon Ball Z and Gundam Wing.
Similarly, Shaman King, though beloved in Japan, never found a lasting audience abroad despite its influence on modern anime like Bleach and Demon Slayer. This pattern of missed opportunities raises questions about how older, foundational series can succeed in a world where the anime landscape is constantly evolving.
The Case for a Kinnikuman Remake
A potential solution for Kinnikuman lies in the growing trend of anime remakes. The success of Dragon Ball Z Kai, which streamlined the Dragon Ball Z series and improved its visuals, proved that updating a classic series can revitalize its appeal. However, simply remastering the original Kinnikuman anime or dubbing a newer iteration like Kinnikuman: Perfect Origin Arc would not be enough to turn the tide.
Instead, a full-fledged remake that remains true to the original manga while modernizing the animation and pacing would be essential. To succeed, the remake would need to offer an English dub that captures the series’ quirky humor and keeps it true to the source material, avoiding the censorship that marred the original Ultimate Muscle dub. A strong production studio and a platform like Netflix could help introduce Kinnikuman to a global audience, emphasizing its importance to the evolution of the shonen genre.
Conclusion
While Kinnikuman may never reach the same level of international fame as its more popular successors, a thoughtful and respectful remake could finally allow this classic series to receive the global recognition it deserves. With a new generation of viewers discovering the series’ influence on the anime landscape, Kinnikuman could once again prove that it has more to offer than just its status as a retro curiosity.
Related Topics
The 10 Best Anime Movies for Makoto Shinkai Fans
‘SPY x FAMILY’ Season 3: Renewal Status and What’s Next
10 Best Anime Films Directed by Makoto Shinkai, Ranked