A popular fan theory suggests that the final island in One Piece, Laugh Tale, may require a significant sacrifice—one that even the most determined pirates may be unwilling to make. According to the theory, Devil Fruit users might have to relinquish their powers to reach the elusive treasure known as the One Piece.
A Sacrifice Beyond Measure
One Piece creator Eiichiro Oda has masterfully woven countless mysteries into the series, with the nature of Gol D. Roger’s treasure, the One Piece, standing as the greatest enigma of all. While numerous theories abound, one in particular speculates that the journey to Laugh Tale could demand a sacrifice that most would find unbearable. Could Oda have hinted at this all along?
Laugh Tale is the final destination in the Grand Line and the location of the legendary treasure. However, a growing theory suggests that reaching this island may come at a steep price for those who possess Devil Fruit abilities.
Hints from the Past
When Gol D. Roger’s crew reached Laugh Tale, two notable members—Buggy and Shanks—were left behind. Buggy’s absence was due to an illness, but fans have long speculated that this might be more than just a coincidence. As the only Devil Fruit user among those mentioned, Buggy’s sudden illness could indicate that Laugh Tale has a unique effect on Devil Fruit users, making it impossible for them to reach the island.
Shanks, who did not go to Laugh Tale, now seeks the treasure, but none of his Red Hair Pirates are Devil Fruit users. This choice seems deliberate, suggesting that Shanks might already know something crucial about the island and its relationship with Devil Fruit abilities.
Luffy’s Path to Ultimate Freedom
The theory further suggests that Laugh Tale might present Devil Fruit users with a choice: surrender their powers or abandon their quest for the One Piece. Throughout the series, the desire for power—especially through Devil Fruits—has driven many characters. But Luffy, the series’ protagonist, has never sought power for its own sake.
Luffy’s goal is to become the Pirate King, not for domination, but for ultimate freedom. He’s already shown a willingness to sacrifice anything that stands in the way of his dream. If giving up his Devil Fruit powers is the price of reaching Laugh Tale and the One Piece, Luffy would likely make that choice without hesitation.
Ironically, losing his Devil Fruit ability might bring Luffy closer to the freedom he craves. By giving up the Nika fruit, he would regain the ability to swim—symbolizing a return to true freedom.
As the series edges closer to its conclusion, this theory gains traction among fans. Whether or not it proves true, it captures the essence of what One Piece has always been about: the pursuit of freedom and the sacrifices one must make along the way.