Adapting romance manga into anime might seem straightforward, especially compared to genres like horror. However, several factors, including narrative style and mature themes, can make certain manga better suited for live-action adaptations. In particular, josei romances often transition to live-action due to their grounded stories and audience preferences. Here are six romance manga that face significant challenges when it comes to being adapted into anime.
1. Happy Marriage!?
Release Date: June 2009
Creator: Maki Enjouji
Volumes: 10
Happy Marriage!? is a classic example of a josei manga that has already been adapted into live-action but not anime. While the success of other josei anime like My Happy Marriage could inspire similar adaptations, Happy Marriage!? works better in live-action due to its grounded and simple romance plot. The series lacks the fantasy or action elements often found in anime, making it more challenging to capture the slow-burn relationship between Chiwa and Hokuto in an animated format.
2. House of the Sun
Release Date: 2010
Creator: Taamo
Volumes: 13
Despite its popularity and critical acclaim, House of the Sun has yet to receive an anime adaptation. The manga, which won the Kodansha Award for Best Shojo in 2014, explores sensitive themes like parental abandonment and emotional healing. These elements need to be treated delicately in any adaptation. Additionally, the gradual character development and internal monologues central to the story would be difficult to condense into a typical 12-episode anime series.
3. You’re My Pet
Release Date: 2000
Creator: Yayoi Ogawa
Volumes: 14
You’re My Pet (also known as Tramps Like Us) is a well-known josei romance that has received multiple live-action adaptations, including two dramas and a South Korean film. The manga gained critical acclaim for its unconventional romance and exploration of gender roles. However, its soap opera-like plot and social commentary on relationship expectations make it better suited for live-action. The complex themes of gender role reversal may not resonate with mainstream anime audiences, which is likely why an anime adaptation has never materialized.
4. Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan
Release Date: 2007
Creator: Gong Ji-Young
Volumes: 1
One of the primary reasons Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan has not been adapted into anime is its heavy subject matter. The story revolves around a suicidal woman and a death row inmate, tackling controversial themes like suicide and existential despair. Adapting such a sensitive narrative into an anime would require a delicate approach, as there’s a risk of sensationalizing or mishandling these topics in a visual medium.
5. Mars
Release Date: 1996
Creator: Fuyumi Soryo
Volumes: 15
Mars is a romance manga that delves into dark and difficult topics such as bullying, sexual assault, and trauma. These heavy themes are interwoven with the romantic storyline, making it similar to a soap opera, which is why it was adapted into a Taiwanese drama in 2004. While some anime explore these themes, balancing them with the romance in Mars would likely lead to an overly melodramatic adaptation. Compressing the complex relationship between the main characters into a 12- or 24-episode anime would also risk losing the emotional depth of the story.
6. Solanin
Release Date: 2005
Creator: Inio Asano
Volumes: 2
Inio Asano is famous for creating deeply introspective manga that are notoriously hard to adapt, with Solanin being no exception. Despite its focus on music, the manga’s slow pace and realistic storytelling make it more suitable for a live-action format. The intricate backgrounds and unique art style would be challenging to recreate in anime form. As a result, fans of the manga should turn to the live-action film adaptation to experience the story, especially its musical elements, which are brought to life on screen.
While romance manga may seem easier to adapt into anime than other genres, these six titles prove that some stories are better suited for live-action due to their mature themes, complex narratives, and introspective storytelling styles.
Related Topics
10 Best and Most Rewatchable Anime Series of the 2000s
9 Worst Anime from Summer 2024, Ranked
How Did Sailor Moon Crystal Differ From The Original Anime?