The “Naruto” series, created by Masashi Kishimoto, presents a complex and rich narrative, filled with intricate characters and pivotal moments. One of the most significant characters in this saga is Itachi Uchiha, whose choices and actions have far-reaching consequences in the world of shinobi. Known for his tragic decision to massacre his own clan to prevent a coup, Itachi’s story is one of sacrifice and duty. But what if Itachi had chosen to side with the Uchiha instead? This comprehensive analysis explores the potential outcomes and implications of such a decision on the story and characters of “Naruto.”
The Uchiha Clan and Its Dilemma
The Roots of Discontent
The Uchiha clan, one of the founding clans of Konohagakure (the Village Hidden in the Leaves), has a storied history of pride and power. However, despite their contributions to the village, the Uchiha felt marginalized and mistrusted by the village’s leadership. This alienation was exacerbated by their forced relocation to the outskirts of the village and the surveillance they were subjected to by the village’s leadership.
The Planned Coup
Frustration and resentment grew within the clan, leading to the formulation of a coup d’état to overthrow the Hokage and seize control of the village. Fugaku Uchiha, the clan leader and Itachi’s father, spearheaded this plan, believing it was the only way to restore the clan’s honor and power.
Itachi’s Original Decision
The Double Agent
Itachi Uchiha, a prodigious shinobi, found himself caught between his love for his family and his loyalty to the village. Ultimately, he chose to side with the village, becoming a double agent for Konoha. Under the direction of the Third Hokage, Hiruzen Sarutobi, and the village’s covert operations unit, Itachi agreed to massacre his own clan to prevent the coup and the potential civil war it would ignite.
The Aftermath
Itachi’s actions led to the near extinction of the Uchiha clan, with only his younger brother, Sasuke, left alive. This decision marked Itachi as a traitor in the eyes of the village and his brother, but he continued to work from the shadows to protect Konoha and guide Sasuke towards a path of strength and revenge.
The Alternative Scenario: Itachi Sides with the Uchiha
Immediate Consequences
Had Itachi chosen to side with the Uchiha clan, the immediate consequence would have been the initiation of the coup. Itachi’s immense power and strategic acumen would have significantly bolstered the clan’s chances of success. His participation could have tipped the scales in favor of the Uchiha, potentially leading to the overthrow of the Hokage.
The Civil War
The coup would have likely triggered a brutal civil war within Konoha. The village’s other powerful clans, including the Hyuga, Nara, Yamanaka, and Akimichi, would have been forced to choose sides. The resulting conflict would have devastated the village, causing countless casualties and weakening Konoha’s defenses against external threats.
Impact on Key Characters
Sasuke Uchiha
In this alternate scenario, Sasuke’s fate would be profoundly altered. Instead of growing up with a burning desire for revenge against Itachi, he would have been raised as part of a victorious or defeated Uchiha clan, depending on the outcome of the coup. His path could diverge in several ways:
Victorious Uchiha: If the Uchiha succeeded, Sasuke might have grown up in a position of power, potentially harboring resentment towards the village’s former leadership. His relationships with other characters, such as Naruto, Sakura, and Kakashi, would be fundamentally different.
Defeated Uchiha: If the coup failed, Sasuke could find himself on the run with the remnants of the Uchiha clan. This scenario might lead him to develop a different kind of hatred and ambition, possibly directing his anger towards the village and its leaders.
Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto’s journey as a shinobi is deeply intertwined with his relationship with Sasuke. In this alternate timeline, the dynamics of their bond would be drastically altered. Naruto’s goal of bringing Sasuke back to the village might instead become a mission to either reconcile with or oppose Sasuke, depending on the outcome of the coup.
See Also: Why Did Ash’s Pikachu Never Evolve?
Konoha Leadership
The leadership of Konoha would face significant changes as well. If the Uchiha coup succeeded, the political landscape of the village would be transformed, potentially leading to a more authoritarian regime under Uchiha rule. Alternatively, if the coup failed, the village’s leadership might impose even harsher measures to prevent future insurrections, fostering further distrust and division.
Akatsuki and Global Implications
Itachi’s role in the Akatsuki would also be affected. As a member of the rogue ninja organization, Itachi played a critical part in their operations while secretly protecting Konoha. Siding with the Uchiha could mean that Itachi never joins the Akatsuki, or if he does, his motivations and actions within the organization would be different.
The ripple effects of the Uchiha coup would extend beyond Konoha, affecting the balance of power among the five great ninja villages. A weakened Konoha, whether due to internal strife or a shift in leadership, would alter the dynamics of international relations and potentially embolden rival villages like Iwagakure, Sunagakure, and Kumogakure.
The Philosophical and Ethical Dimensions
Loyalty and Sacrifice
Itachi’s original decision to massacre his clan raises profound questions about loyalty and sacrifice. By choosing to side with the village, Itachi prioritized the greater good over his personal attachments, embodying the philosophy of utilitarianism. If he had sided with the Uchiha, it would highlight the tension between familial loyalty and duty to a larger community.
Power and Responsibility
The Uchiha coup scenario underscores the theme of power and its responsible use. The Uchiha’s desire for power and autonomy clashed with the village’s need for stability and unity. Itachi’s decision to support or oppose the coup would reflect his beliefs about power and its role in achieving peace.
The Cycle of Hatred
A central theme in “Naruto” is the cycle of hatred and revenge. Itachi’s original actions were intended to break this cycle by preventing a larger conflict. Siding with the Uchiha, however, would perpetuate the cycle, leading to further violence and retribution. This alternate scenario would offer a stark illustration of how different choices can either mitigate or exacerbate the cycle of hatred.
Narrative and Thematic Implications
Character Development
Itachi’s choice to side with the Uchiha would result in drastically different character arcs for many of the main characters. Sasuke’s development, in particular, would be significantly impacted. His motivations, relationships, and ultimate goals would change, potentially leading him down a darker path or allowing for different forms of redemption.
Plot Divergence
The “Naruto” series would take a markedly different trajectory with Itachi siding with the Uchiha. Key events, such as the formation of Team 7, the Chunin Exams, and the Fourth Great Ninja War, would unfold differently. The series’ overarching themes of friendship, perseverance, and redemption would be explored through new and varied lenses.
Exploration of Themes
An alternate storyline where Itachi sides with the Uchiha would provide an opportunity to delve deeper into themes of power, loyalty, and the consequences of rebellion. It would also allow for a more nuanced exploration of the Uchiha clan’s grievances and the ethical dilemmas faced by those in positions of power.
Conclusion
The decision of Itachi Uchiha to side with his clan instead of the village represents a significant divergence point in the “Naruto” narrative. This alternate scenario would lead to profound changes in the story’s plot, character dynamics, and thematic explorations. While the actual series presents Itachi’s choice as a tragic but necessary sacrifice for the greater good, imagining a world where he sides with the Uchiha offers a fascinating glimpse into the complexities of loyalty, power, and the cycle of hatred. Ultimately, Itachi’s story, whether as a clan loyalist or a village protector, remains a poignant reflection on the difficult choices faced by those who strive to balance personal bonds with broader responsibilities.